Skip to Content

Steak and Guinness Pie

Bluebonnets and Brownies


1 hour
1 pie

The other week, Jennie put out the request that we all make a peanut butter pie for the ones we love.

I was definitely inspired, only, the one I love is as anti-peanut butter as you can get without actually being allergic to peanuts.

I was pretty sure if I presented James with a peanut butter pie, he would have stuck his tongue out at me and turned his nose up.

But the sentiment Jennie passed on, I took to heart. James has been begging me for two years now to create a Steak & Guinness pie recipe for him. Something like he’d find at the finest (or dingiest – often the same thing) chippy in all of England.

So that week, while everyone else was making peanut butter pies, I set to work on a Steak & Guinness pie filling for my Brit.

I think Jennie’s reminder is a great one – if a loved one has asked a special request, don’t put it off. Life gets in the way all the time. Remember that the dishes and dusting can wait.

Steak and Guinness Pie

I cooked them up in our Breville personal pie maker – a recent purchase and obsession brought into our lives by the awesome Casey – but you can make a standard 8″ or 9″ pie too, and serve wedges instead of individual pies.

For those of you that do have a Breville Personal Pie Maker, there is enough filling here to make 8 pies.

Steak and Guinness Pie

[wpurp-searchable-recipe]Steak and Guinness Pie – – – [/wpurp-searchable-recipe]

Easy Chicken and Dumplings
Kahlua Pie makes the world go 'round. It's true. It's not love, it's kahlua pie.
Nanny's Kahlua Pie

bristol plasterer

Tuesday 15th of September 2015

Lovely, top marks for this. Tastes great. Thanks.



Monday 12th of September 2011

I wish my local chippy would sell steak and guinness pie, that would be awesome!

Sunny Hernandez (@foryourpiesonly)

Monday 5th of September 2011

p.s. I have been eyeing that pie maker for so long now...I dunno how much longer I can hold out! Haha.

Sunny Hernandez (@foryourpiesonly)

Monday 5th of September 2011

I lovvvve steak & ale pie! If you're ever looking for a little variation, I make mine with a spiced cheddar cheese crust. It is cold winter night decadence :)

Jen @ My Kitchen Addiction

Friday 2nd of September 2011

Yum! Those pies look so perfect. I've been wondering about that Breville pie maker, but it certainly made some nice looking pies. (Though, I am so done with one-purpose kitchen appliances... until I get a bigger kitchen!)

Need to add this to the fall menu!